What is the best story in the Gospel? Peter’s denial! +video

What is the best story in the Gospel? Peter’s denial! +video

In an interview with Stephen Berry, René Girard noted that one of the greatest scenes in the Gospel in from the literature, the denial, is by Peter.

This is because of Peter symbol for all people. One cannot resist the “mimetic contagion,” said Girard. Peter’s Denial is therefore the best seen in the gospel.

If you are in a crowd, you are literally contaminated by the crowd in a crowd.

One of the things that the Gospel tells us of an anthropological perspective is to demonstrate the omnipotence of the crowd.

And that only Jesus can conquer the power of the public.

Girard notes that this remembers him from attempting to Christianity to adapt to the many voices in culture (because that’s the crowd).

Rene Girard on Peter denial, the best scène in the gospel
René Girard over Petrus ontkenning.

A young girl elicits Peter’s denial.

He looks at the words in the Gospel of John that tells us about the girl who accuses Peter that he is a disciple of Jesus.

It was a young girl (παιδίσκη).

Girard will find this important.

Why is stated that they are young?

Not because he thinks Peter will be tempted sexually, but that the girl has a job that would not have an old woman. Maybe if she was an old woman she would not, similarly, respond to Peter. Another thing that the gospel us says that the young girl.

Peter’s accent, recognized as being of Galilee. What marks him as a foreigner? She was drawing lines, making them substantially Peter Marks if not part of the crowd. So, what do all the people when they are excluded from a group? They want to prove that they have related equipment.

Peter would like to show that he is on the side of the crowd. And because the only way to show is that you become part of the crowd and has joined the scapegoat mechanism.

If I have the same enemy, I am one of you.

Peter finds himself that the mob slaughter sacrifices Jesus as a scapegoat.

So, in the gospel you get subtle hints about Peter’s motivation, that are universally human.

That’s why Peter should not be labelled as a “weak” person for betraying Jesus.

Peter represents all the apostles because he is the leader.

This is why Girard, the scene of Peter’s denial and find absolutely priceless.

Girard asks rhetorically, how can we all?

The convictions have our time?

Only a few centuries ago, everyone had faith in God automatically.

Rene Girard on Peter denial, the best scène in the gospel

Now, everyone does not automatically believe in him.

But that is purely the crowd phenomenon.

And it is not due to the “strong scientific arguments”.

It is just Peter his denial.


That’s all it is.

Girard makes a very striking assertion that Peter’s denial story in John’s Gospel is an infinitely more powerful story in what society than any other text.

But then there is also the fact that Peter is unaware of what he is doing.

Girard notes that this is significant.

The Gospels do not tell us that Peter was unaware of what he was doing,

Instead, he says that the rooster crowed the third time and did Peter remembering what he had forgotten, exactly that thing that Jesus had foretold.

Because Jesus listening to his Father, he understood the human condition and mimetic desire and that Peter would be part of the audience.

If you have additional suggestions, I’d love to hear! Place your comments below.

Waardering: 1 uit 5.

Read more